Does TanStack Query replace Redux, MobX or other global state managers?

Well, let's start with a few important items:

• TanStack Query is a server-state library, responsible for managing asynchronous operations between your server and client
• Redux, MobX, Zustand, etc. are client-state libraries that can be used to store asynchronous data, albeit inefficiently when compared to a tool like TanStack Query

With those points in mind, the short answer is that TanStack Query replaces the boilerplate code and related wiring used to manage cache data in your client-state and replaces it with just a few lines of code.

For a vast majority of applications, the truly globally accessible client state that is left over after migrating all of your async code to TanStack Query is usually very tiny.

There are still some circumstances where an application might indeed have a massive amount of synchronous client-only state (like a visual designer or music production application), in which case, you will probably still want a client state manager. In this situation it's important to note that TanStack Query is not a replacement for local/client state management. However, you can use TanStack Query alongside most client state managers with zero issues.

Here we have some "global" state being managed by a global state library:

const globalState = {
  projects,
  teams,
  tasks,
  users,
  themeMode,
  sidebarStatus,
}

const globalState = {
  projects,
  teams,
  tasks,
  users,
  themeMode,
  sidebarStatus,
}

Currently, the global state manager is caching 4 types of server-state: projects, teams, tasks, and users. If we were to move these server-state assets to TanStack Query, our remaining global state would look more like this:

const globalState = {
  themeMode,
  sidebarStatus,
}

const globalState = {
  themeMode,
  sidebarStatus,
}

This also means that with a few function calls to injectQuery and injectMutation, we also get to remove any boilerplate code that was used to manage our server state e.g.

• Connectors
• Action Creators
• Middlewares
• Reducers
• Loading/Error/Result states
• Contexts

With all of those things removed, you may ask yourself, "Is it worth it to keep using our client state manager for this tiny global state?"

And that's up to you!

But TanStack Query's role is clear. It removes asynchronous wiring and boilerplate from your application and replaces it with just a few lines of code.

What are you waiting for, give it a go already!